| Player | Voter |
| Andy Ashby | @DanielNava |
| Oscar Azocar | @sdsuaztec4 |
| Mark Bellhorn | @hollinger |
| Lance Blankenship | @NorCalBono |
| John Boccabella | @braggers41 |
| Scott Brosius | @ChristinaKahrl |
| Archi Cianfrocco | @swathen83 |
| Brian Daubach | @dpwoods5 |
| Chris Denorfia | @GhostOfRayAKroc |
| Lew Ford | @KarlGAnderson |
| Butch Huskey | @howardmegdal |
| Ron Karkovice | @Reaginsnomics |
| Ryan Klesko | @Baseballblahs |
| Terry Leach | @baseballcrank |
| Keith Miller | @dastudes |
| Jack Morris | @mattymatty2000 |
| Phil Nevin | @BigFrog619 |
| Phil Plantier | @ducksnorts |
| Alfonso Soriano | @firstheart42 |
| Shane Spencer | @thejamootz |
| Champ Summers | @George11Best |
I'm sure they feel quite honored. Thanks to all who participated. Maybe we'll do it again someday.
